Coverart for item
The Resource Proportionality and the rule of law : rights, justification, reasoning, edited by Grant Huscroft, Western University, Canada; Bradley W. Miller, Western University, Canada; Gregoire Webber, London School of Economics

Proportionality and the rule of law : rights, justification, reasoning, edited by Grant Huscroft, Western University, Canada; Bradley W. Miller, Western University, Canada; Gregoire Webber, London School of Economics

Label
Proportionality and the rule of law : rights, justification, reasoning
Title
Proportionality and the rule of law
Title remainder
rights, justification, reasoning
Statement of responsibility
edited by Grant Huscroft, Western University, Canada; Bradley W. Miller, Western University, Canada; Gregoire Webber, London School of Economics
Contributor
Editor
Subject
Language
eng
Summary
"To speak of human rights is to speak of proportionality. It is no exaggeration to claim that proportionality has overtaken rights as the orienting idea in contemporary human rights law and scholarship. Proportionality has been received into the constitutional doctrine of courts in continental Europe, the United Kingdom, Canada, New Zealand, Israel, and South Africa, as well as the jurisprudence of treaty-based legal systems like the European Court of Human Rights, giving rise to claims of a global model, a received approach, or, simply, the best-practice standard of rights adjudication. Even in the United States, which is widely understood to have formally rejected proportionality, some argue that the various levels of scrutiny adopted by the US Supreme Court are analogous to the standard questions posed by proportionality. As proportionality scholars are well aware, some of the early literature on balancing and rights is American, with special reference to the First Amendment. Notwithstanding proportionality's popularity, there is no consensus on its methodology. Much less does the use of a proportionality doctrine guarantee consensus on substantive rights questions. What the principle of proportionality promises is a common analytical framework, a framework the significance of which is not in its ubiquity (a mere fact), but because its structure influences (some would say controls) how courts reason to conclusions in many of the great moral and political questions confronting political communities. As a framework, proportionality analysis is superficially straightforward, setting out four questions in evaluating whether the limitation of a right is justifiable. A serviceable - but by no means canonical"--
Assigning source
Provided by publisher
Cataloging source
DLC
Index
index present
LC call number
K247
LC item number
.P76 2014
Literary form
non fiction
Nature of contents
bibliography
http://library.link/vocab/relatedWorkOrContributorDate
1968-
http://library.link/vocab/relatedWorkOrContributorName
  • Huscroft, Grant
  • Miller, Bradley W.
  • Webber, Grégoire C. N.
http://library.link/vocab/subjectName
  • Proportionality in law
  • Human rights
  • Rule of law
Label
Proportionality and the rule of law : rights, justification, reasoning, edited by Grant Huscroft, Western University, Canada; Bradley W. Miller, Western University, Canada; Gregoire Webber, London School of Economics
Instantiates
Publication
Bibliography note
Includes bibliographical references and index
Contents
Introduction / Grant Huscroft, Bradley W. Miller and Gregoire Webber -- The lost meaning of proportionality / Martin Luteran -- Proportionality is dead : long live proportionality! / Alison L. Young -- Human dignity and proportionality : deontic pluralism in balancing / Mattias Kumm and Alec D. Walen -- Between reason and strategy : some reflections on the normativity of proportionality / George Pavlakos -- On the loss of rights / Gregoire Webber -- Proportionality and rights inflation / Kai Moller -- Proportionality and the question of weight / Frederick Schauer -- Proportionality and the relevance of interpretation / Grant Huscroft -- Democracy, legality and proportionality / T.R.S. Allan -- Proportionality and deference in a culture of justification / David Dyzenhaus -- Proportionality and democratic constitutionalism / Stephen Gardbaum -- The rationalism of proportionality's culture of justification / Mark Antaki -- Proportionality and incommensurability / Timothy Endicott -- Legislating proportionately / Richard Ekins -- Proportionality's blind spot : 'neutrality' and political philosophy / Bradley W. Miller -- Mapping the American debate over balancing / Iddo Porat
Control code
17932406
Dimensions
24 cm
Extent
ix, 421 p
Isbn
9781107647954
Lccn
2013044707
Note
Law packs 3-5 bib class law
Label
Proportionality and the rule of law : rights, justification, reasoning, edited by Grant Huscroft, Western University, Canada; Bradley W. Miller, Western University, Canada; Gregoire Webber, London School of Economics
Publication
Bibliography note
Includes bibliographical references and index
Contents
Introduction / Grant Huscroft, Bradley W. Miller and Gregoire Webber -- The lost meaning of proportionality / Martin Luteran -- Proportionality is dead : long live proportionality! / Alison L. Young -- Human dignity and proportionality : deontic pluralism in balancing / Mattias Kumm and Alec D. Walen -- Between reason and strategy : some reflections on the normativity of proportionality / George Pavlakos -- On the loss of rights / Gregoire Webber -- Proportionality and rights inflation / Kai Moller -- Proportionality and the question of weight / Frederick Schauer -- Proportionality and the relevance of interpretation / Grant Huscroft -- Democracy, legality and proportionality / T.R.S. Allan -- Proportionality and deference in a culture of justification / David Dyzenhaus -- Proportionality and democratic constitutionalism / Stephen Gardbaum -- The rationalism of proportionality's culture of justification / Mark Antaki -- Proportionality and incommensurability / Timothy Endicott -- Legislating proportionately / Richard Ekins -- Proportionality's blind spot : 'neutrality' and political philosophy / Bradley W. Miller -- Mapping the American debate over balancing / Iddo Porat
Control code
17932406
Dimensions
24 cm
Extent
ix, 421 p
Isbn
9781107647954
Lccn
2013044707
Note
Law packs 3-5 bib class law

Library Locations

    • Sydney Jones LibraryBorrow it
      Chatham Street, Liverpool, L7 7BD, GB
      53.403069 -2.963723